Thoughts From The Valley
The Hangover
How I am feeling: Disappointed. No getting around it, really, folks. I believe in my heart that Penn State had the better team than Michigan this year. But my worst fears came to fruition, once again, on Saturday, when the Penn State coaching staff (or, more specifically, the offensive coaching staff) walked into Ann Arbor with the same old philosophy: "The defense will win this for us. Let's just not screw it up." Remarkably, they screwed it up anyway. If Penn State scores a single touchdown on Saturday, they win. They couldn't even muster that. All due credit to Michigan, however, and especially gutty freshman quarterback Ryan Mallett.
What I am drinking: Smuttynose Brewing Company Pumpkin Ale. Before you judge me, let me speak these two points: 1) Smuttynose (of New Hampshire) is one of the finest craft breweries in the nation; 2) This pumpkin ale is not your standard pumpkin ale. Taking a page from their their Pilgrim forefathers (who utilized the autumn pumpkin crop to extend the brewing season), Smuttynose has crafted a subtle, drinkable and powerful (6.0 percent ABV) brew that is perfect for September sipping. Enjoy, folks.
What I am listening to: Neil Young, Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere: Sometime in the fall of 1994, I took a class trip for a freshman-level American history class at Penn State. The trip was to Fallingwater, Frank Lloyd Wright's signature masterpiece. And on that two-hour drive to Fallingwater, I listened to Neil Young's Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere for the first time. Surrounded by the sights of the autumn leaves of central Pennsylvania and the sounds Neil Young's remarkable guitar work, I was extremely happy (also, it should be noted, we had just beaten Ohio State, 63-14, the day before). This remains one of my favorite college football season records.
My thoughts on the weekend:Folks, I cannot mask my disappointment. It is real. It is tangible. Just as Mrs. Your Editor. She is living with it.
But you know what? This afternoon, after spending a few hours watching NFL football (Steelers, Eagles, etc.) with TCFA Friend Scott Burke, Your Editor drove home through Philadelphia's beautiful Fairmount Park, just now turning yellow/orange/red with autumn's arrival, and enjoyed a moment of peace and clarity.
What did this moment tell me? Well, I'll tell you. It told me the following:
1) Things could be worse. My Nits are 3-1. Ranked No. 21 and No. 19 in the respective "polls." There is, in the words of Lee Corso, "a lot of football to be played."
2) Joe Paterno, despite his shortcomings in offensive gameplanning, is right about this (famous JoePa quote to follow): "You are never as good as you think you are when you win, and you are never as bad as you think you are when you lose." Please take a second to let the great, simple wisdom of that quote sink in, folks.
3) I am still a Nittany Lion.
We love our teams, folks, and we love them no matter what.
Somewhere in this great nation, there is a man with a basement bar dedicated to Kentucky football. And for the better part of the past century, this man has suffered. Greatly. But you know what? This season, he is the happiest man on the planet. Because Kentucky just beat Louisville and Arkansas back-to-back.
Today, in that basement bar dedicated to Kentucky, that man is drinking bourbon. He is watching ESPN analysts talk about how great the Wildcats are. And he is thinking this: "There is nothing better than being a Kentucky football fan."
That's how I felt two weeks ago, when Penn State beat Notre Dame (little did I know how bad Notre Dame was). But regardless, I sit here today and realize that my life as a Penn State fan has not been that bad.
And I also realize there are better days ahead.
In fact, there are better days ahead in exactly five days. Saturday awaits.
Three Yards and a Cloud of Dust
Three ...: OK, enough whining about Penn State. The time has come to offer kudos to a Big Ten team that actually took care of business this weekend: And so, now, TCFA offers its hats-off treatment to the Michigan Wolverines, and, more specifically, the remarkable effort of tailback Mike Hart. Hart carried the ball 44 times against Penn State. He took numerous licks from linebackers Dan Connor and Sean Lee. But even though Hart was banged up, and even though he was battling Strep Throat (believe it or not, folks), he kept battling, kept pushing, and never once left the ballgame. Hart is not the fastest back in the country. He is not the biggest. He is not the strongest. But he may well be the best.
Two ...: The text message, sent by TCFA Friend and Georgia alum Brian M. Schleter, arrived on Your Editor's phone approximately five seconds after the game ended--"Richt now 22-3 in SEC road games." Yes, Georgia coach Mark Richt just won another road game in the brutal SEC, this time taking down a rising Alabama squad on their home turf, in overtime, on quarterback Matt Stafford's absolutely perfect game-winning touchdown pass to Mikey Henderson (and if there is a more underappreciated superstar in the country than Henderson, I haven't seen him). Georgia gave up big leads twice, but unlike most other teams in similar spots, the 'Dawgs kept their heads in the game and, more importantly, got the road SEC win (no small task) once again. That focus and effort can be credited to Richt, who despite not having posted much "championship" success, is one of the best and brightest young coaches in the country.
One ...: Surprise, surprise. Ohio State once again appears to be the best team in the Big Ten. Why I am not surprised by that?
Touchdown ...: In the days leading up to Penn State's loss to Michigan, Harrisburg Patriot News writer David Jones practically begged Penn State's offensive braintrust to open up the offense--to, for once, take some chances down the field, utilize quarterback Anthony Morelli's singular asset (his rocket arm) and get the ball to those great wide receivers that the Nittany Lion staff worked so hard to recruit. But what did the coaches do on Saturday? They curled up into a little ball. They ran with our horrible running game. They handed the game to Michigan. As Jones wrote on Sunday, Penn State came out with a game plan that dated to "World War I." And it seems the conservative approach was not lost on Morelli, who, when asked after the game what he thought of the gameplan, offered this: "I don't call the plays. You'll have to ask the coaches about that. I just want to win.'' So the question, now, is this: Where does Penn State go from here? With a trip to Illinois looming, do the leaders step up and get the team back on track? Do the players realize how much there remains to play for? Your Editor believes the talent is there to win out. I really believe that. But whether or not that happens, well, that's up to the players. Or maybe more importantly, it's up to the coaches--who need to realize, finally, that the old "World War I" approach will not cut it.
Connect with TCFA

Our show is now on Stitcher!
Listen to us on your iPhone, Android Phone, BlackBerry and WebOS phones. Stitcher is Smart Radio for Your phone. Find it in your app store or at stitcher.com
Stitcher SmartRadio- The Smarter Way to listen to radio
Love TCFA?
Please consider supporting TCFA with your kind donation.
About this blog
Welcome to The College Football Athenaeum, home of the intelligent college football fan. You have found a college football magazine unlike any other, a site where the game is studied and savored, discussed and enjoyed, loved and celebrated. More about TCFA
2012 Season
- Apr 13, 2012
Podcast, Episode 50 - Mar 8, 2012
Podcast, Episode 49 - Feb 3, 2012
Podcast, Episode 48 - Jan 25, 2012
An Honest Assessment of an Immeasurable Life - Jan 13, 2012
Podcast, Episode 47 - Jan 5, 2012
Podcast, Episode 46
2011 Season
- Dec 29, 2011
Podcast, Episode 45 - Dec 22, 2011
Podcast, Episode 44 - Dec 15, 2011
Podcast, Episode 43 - Dec 9, 2011
Podcast, Episode 42 - Dec 6, 2011
Over And Out - Dec 2, 2011
At Season's End, What Is Left? - Dec 1, 2011
Podcast, Episode 41 - Nov 27, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: The End Draws Near - Nov 24, 2011
Podcast, Episode 40 - Nov 21, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: For One Day, We Achieved Perfection - Nov 18, 2011
Make Alternate Plans - Nov 17, 2011
Podcast, Episode 39 - Nov 14, 2011
Thoughts From the Valley: The First Nervous Step Toward Redemption - Nov 11, 2011
In The Darkness. Seeking The Light. - Nov 10, 2011
Podcast, Episode 38 - Nov 7, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: We Were Fools - Nov 4, 2011
Dying Dreams, the Loss of Hope, and Metaphorical Kicks in the Teeth - Nov 3, 2011
Podcast, Episode 37 - Oct 31, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: Surviving. Advancing. - Oct 28, 2011
Our Loyalty is Being Tested
 - Oct 27, 2011
Podcast, Episode 36 - Oct 24, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: A Very Good Kind of Nervousness - Oct 20, 2011
Podcast, Episode 35 - Oct 20, 2011
What The Playoff Proponents Don’t Understand 

 - Oct 17, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: Confusion and Happiness - Oct 14, 2011
Urban Meyer and the Suddenly Expanded College Football Universe - Oct 13, 2011
Podcast, Episode 34 - Oct 10, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: Back To Reality. - Oct 7, 2011
Back to Happy Valley. On a Mission. - Oct 6, 2011
Podcast, Episode 33 - Oct 3, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: Honesty and Joylessness - Sep 30, 2011
October Has Arrived. And With It, Perfection. - Sep 29, 2011
Podcast, Episode 32 - Sep 26, 2011
Thoughts from The Valley: There is The Grove. And Then There is Everything Else. - Sep 23, 2011
Money First. Everything Else Second. - Sep 22, 2011
Podcast, Episode 31 - Sep 18, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: Joe Must Go. And Other Stuff. - Sep 16, 2011
College Football. Four Kids. And How it All Fits Together. - Sep 15, 2011
Podcast, Episode 30 - Sep 12, 2011
I am an Aging Salmon, Swimming Upstream; Also, the Big Ten is Awful - Sep 8, 2011
Podcast, Episode 29 - Sep 8, 2011
A Dynasty In Full Bloom, A Dynasty In Decline - Sep 6, 2011
Thoughts From The Valley: Immediacy and Whiplash - Sep 1, 2011
Podcast, Episode 28 - Sep 1, 2011
Why We Care - Aug 25, 2011
Fate Intervenes. Via Lawyer Tillman. - Aug 24, 2011
Podcast, Episode 27 - Jul 22, 2011
Podcast, Episode 26 - Jun 16, 2011
Podcast, Episode 25 - May 26, 2011
Podcast, Episode 24 - Apr 1, 2011
Podcast, Episode 23 - Mar 4, 2011
Podcast, Episode 22 - Feb 19, 2011
Podcast, Episode 21 - Feb 1, 2011
Podcast, Episode 20 - Jan 7, 2011
Podcast, Episode 19
2010 Season
- Dec 30, 2010
Podcast, Episode 18 - Dec 20, 2010
Podcast, Episode 17 - Dec 12, 2010
TCFA Is On Vacation - Dec 9, 2010
Podcast, Episode 16 - Dec 6, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: The. End. - Dec 2, 2010
The Tyranny of Time - Dec 2, 2010
Podcast, Episode 15 - Nov 28, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: The Season Is Essentially Over. Massive Sigh. - Nov 25, 2010
Podcast, Episode 14 - Nov 25, 2010
Happy Thanksgiving: I'm Not Writing - Nov 22, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: Wrapping Up From Landover - Nov 18, 2010
We Are Up To The Challenge - Nov 18, 2010
Podcast, Episode 13 - Nov 14, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: Resignation And Other Stuff - Nov 11, 2010
A Rivalry Without Respect - Nov 11, 2010
Podcast, Episode 12 - Nov 7, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: McGloin Fever - Nov 4, 2010
Podcast, Episode 11 - Nov 4, 2010
How To Save The Big East - Oct 31, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: Oh My God We Won - Oct 28, 2010
Podcast, Episode 10 - Oct 28, 2010
The Abridged Miserable History of Michigan State Football - Oct 24, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: The Day After - Oct 21, 2010
An Awful Season Demands Nothing Less Than A Bar Tour - Oct 21, 2010
Podcast, Episode 9 - Oct 17, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: A Compelling Case For Boise State - Oct 14, 2010
Podcast, Episode 8 - Oct 13, 2010
Making The Most Of It - Oct 10, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: Apocalypse Now - Oct 8, 2010
Podcast, Episode 7 - Oct 8, 2010
Tailgating Under Attack - Oct 3, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: The Season Is Over. The Season Has Just Begun. - Oct 1, 2010
Why I Love The Big Ten - Sep 30, 2010
Podcast, Episode 6 - Sep 26, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: A Terrifying Near-Loss, And Ten Things To Think About - Sep 23, 2010
Temple. Terrible No More. - Sep 22, 2010
Podcast, Episode 5 - Sep 19, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: A Fake Field Goal. And a Fozzy. - Sep 16, 2010
My Daughter Dilemma - Sep 16, 2010
Podcast, Episode 4 - Sep 12, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: The 'Bama Beatdown and The Awesomeness of Denard Robinson - Sep 9, 2010
Podcast, Episode 3 - Sep 9, 2010
Renewal. Revenge. Respect. - Sep 5, 2010
Thoughts From The Valley: Robinson and Bolden, Florida and Forcier - Sep 2, 2010
College Football Thoughts. Over The Great American Continent. - Sep 2, 2010
Podcast, Episode 2 - Aug 25, 2010
Learning to Love the Game. In the Absence of Glory. - Aug 22, 2010
Our First Podcast - Aug 22, 2010
It's Almost Time. But It's Not Time Yet.
2009 Season
- Dec 9, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley: The End - Dec 4, 2009
The Last Hurrah - Nov 27, 2009
Thoughts from the Valley: Thanksgiving Edition - Nov 23, 2009
Thoughts from the Valley - Nov 20, 2009
Farewell, Big Ten 2009 - Nov 13, 2009
Running, Not Hiding - Nov 9, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Nov 6, 2009
A Very Long Column About The Only Game That Matters - Nov 2, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Oct 30, 2009
The Canon of College Football - Oct 26, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Oct 23, 2009
College Football Is Under Siege - Oct 19, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Oct 16, 2009
College Football Lessons - Oct 12, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Oct 9, 2009
The College Football Wife - Oct 5, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Oct 5, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Oct 2, 2009
Preserve These Places - Sep 28, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Sep 25, 2009
What We Know - Sep 21, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Sep 18, 2009
Mean is Good - Sep 14, 2009
Thoughts From the Valley - Sep 11, 2009
A Tailgating First - Sep 7, 2009
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 4, 2009
Autumn Saturday - Aug 28, 2009
The Moment
2008 Season
- Dec 8, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Dec 5, 2008
Goodbye, College Football - Nov 30, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 28, 2008
The 2008 Thanksgiving Edition - Nov 24, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 21, 2008
'The Satanic Verses' of Midwestern Football - Nov 17, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 14, 2008
Last Trip of the Year - Nov 10, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 7, 2008
No-Fun November - Nov 3, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Oct 31, 2008
What To Do On A Bye Week - Oct 26, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Oct 24, 2008
The Ebb and Flow of a Saturday - Oct 20, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Oct 17, 2008
What Next? - Oct 13, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Oct 10, 2008
Play On, Wisconsin - Oct 6, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Oct 3, 2008
Things We Haven't Seen - Sep 29, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 26, 2008
The Big Lie - Sep 22, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 19, 2008
Three Weeks In ... - Sep 15, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 12, 2008
Bill Plaschke Loves USC - Sep 7, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 5, 2008
What I'm Looking Forward To - Sep 2, 2008
Thoughts From The Valley - Aug 28, 2008
Labor Day, Perfected
2007 Season
- Dec 2, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 30, 2007
The Season In Review - Nov 25, 2007
Thoughts from the Valley - Nov 19, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 16, 2007
The end - Nov 12, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 9, 2007
No refuge - Nov 5, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Nov 2, 2007
November - Oct 29, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Oct 26, 2007
Mud. Slop. Big Ten football. - Oct 19, 2007
Game of the year - Oct 15, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Oct 12, 2007
Cleveland In Philly - Oct 5, 2007
When Saturdays die - Sep 28, 2007
Predictable - Sep 24, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 21, 2007
The Streak - Sep 17, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 10, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Sep 7, 2007
Big Mess - Sep 4, 2007
Thoughts From The Valley - Aug 31, 2007
The Plan - Aug 24, 2007
Remove Your Hats
